What Are The Most Valuable Antique Toys?

What Are The Most Valuable Antique Toys? What are they worth? How do I sell them?

If you are looking to sell vintage toys and collectibles for cash, PGS Gold & Coin is the ideal destination. We are dedicated toy buyers, offering a hassle-free and transparent selling experience. Whether you are wondering “who buys vintage toys near me” or “where to sell old toys for cash,” we are here to assist you.

At PGS Gold & Coin, we buy toys of various types, including vintage Fisher Price toys, action figures, and other collectible items. If you are searching for the best place to sell vintage toys online or want to sell your toys near you, look no further. Our expert team is ready to evaluate your items and offer you a fair price.

We understand the value of vintage toys and collectibles, which is why we strive to provide the best compensation for your items. With our convenient locations across the area, selling your toys has never been easier. Whether you prefer to visit us in person or explore options like “sell my toys app” or “ebay vintage toys,” PGS Gold & Coin is your trusted partner.

Don’t waste time wondering “who buys used toys near me” or “where to sell vintage fisher price toys.” Reach out to PGS Gold & Coin today and turn your vintage toys into cash. We are the collectible toy buyers near you, ready to make the selling process smooth and rewarding.

, What Are The Most Valuable Antique Toys

What are the Highest Value Antique Toys?

The value of antique toys can vary greatly depending on factors such as rarity, condition, age, and historical significance. Here are some of the most valuable antique toys and their approximate values:

1. Steiff Teddy Bears: Steiff is a German company that has been producing teddy bears since the early 20th century. Rare Steiff teddy bears from the early years can be worth several thousand dollars, with some selling for over $100,000.

2. Hot Wheels Cars: Hot Wheels cars were first introduced by Mattel in 1968 and have since become a popular collectible. Rare Hot Wheels cars in good condition can be worth several thousand dollars, with some selling for over $100,000.

3. Barbie Dolls: Barbie dolls were first introduced by Mattel in 1959 and have become a cultural icon. Rare Barbie dolls, such as the original 1959 Barbie or the 1965 Barbie with the Bendable Legs, can be worth several thousand dollars.

4. Lionel Trains: Lionel trains were first produced in the early 1900s and have been popular with collectors ever since. Rare Lionel trains in good condition can be worth several thousand dollars.

5. Lehmann Tin Toys: Lehmann was a German company that produced tin toys in the early 1900s. Rare Lehmann toys, such as the Marklin Fire Pumper or the Lehmann Tut Tut, can be worth several thousand dollars.

, What Are The Most Valuable Antique Toys

If you have valuable antique toys that you would like to sell, there are several options:

1. Auction Houses: You may be able to consign your antique toys to a reputable auction house, such as Sotheby’s or Christie’s, which will sell your items to collectors and take a commission on the sale. It will go up for auction, so as high as it goes at auction you are locked in to that price.

2. Sell Online & become a retailer for the moment, dealing with shipping, returns & customers.
You can put it up for auction on Ebay as well. You can list it, watch the auction and see if anyone bids. If you are a seller, Protect your investment by making absolutely sure your opening price is the least money you would be comfortable with accepting.

Once the item is up for auction you are obligated to sell the item after all bids have concluded.

3. Antique Toy Dealers: You can sell your antique toys to a dealer like PGS who specializes in antique toys. Auction houses take a seller’s fee, so does Etsy or Ebay..PGS will typically offer you just under the top possible value that you might get from selling directly to a collector.

But, with no wait time and a guaranteed higher payment then the outcome of an auction, it’s a quick and convenient option to ensure you get a good amount for your collectible.

Before selling your antique toys, it’s important to do your research and consult with experts to determine their value and ensure that you get a fair price.

What Antique Toys Sell Best?

Antique toys that are in excellent condition and have unique features or historical significance tend to sell better and fetch higher prices among collectors. Here are some factors that can increase the value of antique toys:

1. Rarity: Toys that were only produced in limited quantities or have unique features or variations are highly sought after by collectors.

2. Condition: Toys in excellent condition, with minimal wear or damage, are more valuable than those with significant damage or missing pieces.

3. Age: The age of the toy can also impact its value, with older toys typically being more valuable than newer ones.

4. Brand and Maker: Toys from well-known and respected makers or brands, such as Steiff, Marklin, or Jumeau, are highly valued among collectors.

5. Historical significance: Toys that are tied to a particular historical event or period, such as toys made during wartime or that reflect the popular culture of a specific era, can also be highly valuable.

Some examples of antique toys that tend to sell well include early teddy bears from makers such as Steiff or Ideal, early model trains from makers such as Lionel or Marklin, rare wind-up toys from makers such as Lehmann or Bing, and rare dolls from makers such as Jumeau, Bru, or Kestner. It’s important to note that the market for antique toys can be highly specialized and competitive, and it’s important to do your research and work with reputable appraisers, dealers, or auction houses to ensure that you get a fair price when buying or selling antique toys.





See what PGS Gold & Coin buys.



Learn more about our convenient services.



Learn more about PGS Gold & Coin and our services.




Visit our online store to see what items we have in stock.

Looking to earn some extra cash?

Looking to upgrade your style with something new? Cash in your unwanted gold, silver & platinum jewelry for a fair appraisal at PGS Gold & Coin.

DID YOU KNOW? PGS purchases

Many different types of items:

  • US & Foreign Coins & Currency
  • Bullion- Gold, Silver, Platinum & Palladium,
  • Jewelry- Gold, Silver & Platinum
  • Diamonds & Engagement Rings
  • Sterling Silver Flatware, Tea Sets & Platters
  • Fine Wine & Vintage Liquor
  • Military & Sports Memorabilia
  • Stamp Collections




5 Great Reasons NOT to Clean Old Coins

Should you ever clean old coins?  We share 5 reasons why we don't think so. “I have some old coins that I want to clean before I bring them into your shop…..can you recommend what products I should use to clean them with?”   This is a question we routinely get asked;...

Father’s Day Coin Buying Tips

Coin buying doesn't have to be stressful when it comes to buying a special gift for Dad! Father’s Day is right around the corner, and if your dad is a coin collector, then this time of the year can either be an easy time to purchase a gift for dad, or a challenging...

The Ten Most Valuable Coins in the United States

When folks come into PGS Gold & Coin to sell their coins, the number one thing they want to know of course is how valuable are their coins.  The next thing they want to know is what are the most valuable coins in the United States.  We thought we would share that...

How to Organize and Inventory Your Coin Collection

Having to organize and inventory your coin collection may be something you never thought you would have to do…..especially if you never set out to collect coins as a hobby. For many folks, once the coin collecting bug bites them, they set down a path of collecting,...

Lincoln Pennies: A Great Addition to Your Coin Collection

Over Labor Day weekend we had the pleasure of spending some time in Springfield, IL and taking in a few of the Abraham Lincoln Sites. One thing is certain; there is an awful lot of Lincoln memorabilia that is available to collect! However if space is at a premium for...

What Should I Do With My Coins/Collectibles For Estates

One of the questions that we get asked routinely is “What should I do with my coins, and other collectibles when it comes to my estate?  Should I sell them, or leave them to my heirs? Can you help me decide my best course of action?” We thought we would take this blog...

5 Tips For Keeping Your Jewelry Sparkling

5 Tips For Keeping Your Jewelry Sparkling Your fine jewelry pieces are more than just a status symbol, as certain pieces, like engagement and wedding rings and family heirloom, have a sentimental value that is beyond priceless to both women and men. Tasteful pieces of...

Sell Your Gold As The Gold Price Continues To Climb

Precious metals such as gold, silver, and platinum have always been viewed as sound investments because they tend to either sustain or increase their value.  Historically, there has been an inverse relationship between the price of precious metals and the value of the...

PGS Gold & Coin Opens New Store in Schaumburg, IL

PGS Gold & Coin has been one of the most trusted coin dealers and precious metal specialists in the Chicago suburbs since we started, and we have just opened a new location in Schaumburg, IL to reach more people in Chicagoland.  Those who are looking to buy or...

Why You Should Sell Your Unwanted or Unused Gold Jewelry

Gold is a precious metal that has been valuable to mankind since ancient times.  It has been used throughout history as currency, and for making luxury items such as jewelry, statues, and religious relics.  Even the U.S. dollar was backed by gold until President Nixon...